• DESIGN
  • EVALUATE
  • ANALYZE
  • DISSEMINATE
  • SCALE-UP

Creating Leadership Pathways For Low-income Workers

How screening and training for managers can bridge the productivity gap in the manufacturing sector?

CHALLENGES AND OPPORTUNITIES

The differences in managerial practices partly explain the lower levels of productivity and high levels of abuse present in manufacturing. In the developing world, productivity, wages, and worker retention remain extremely low. To address this issue, we developed a screening questionnaire and analysis algorithm that identifies and trains potential supervisorial candidates. We conducted RCTs in Indian garment factories, which employ 45 million people, to understand whether building pathways to leadership for blue-collar workers can improve firm productivity and reduce workplace harassment.

RESEARCH QUESTION

How can we identify and train workers to be good managers in a way that is cost-effective and easy to adapt, particularly for low-margin, labor-intensive manufacturing firms in developing countries?

RESEARCH DESIGN

Over three years, we conducted extensive research in Indian garment factories through two large-scale randomized controlled trials. Our efforts focused on identifying managerial skills crucial for productivity in low-income contexts and highlighting their undervaluation in the labor market due to measurement challenges. Paired with our soft skills training program for supervisors and mid-level managers, the training includes topics like communication, self-esteem, gender sensitivity, problem-solving, work planning, and harassment prevention. We are also creating mobile applications: one for screening and identifying managerial candidates’ skills and deficiencies and another for targeted training. Developed with a human-centered design, we are piloting the apps in their factories and plan to adapt them for broader use.

FINDINGS AND IMPLICATIONS

Our evaluations indicate:

  • The efficiency of production lines increases by 8%.
  • Women workers with supervisors who were screened and trained through our tools are 20% less likely to experience workplace harassment.

These results show that managers need to learn how to manage. This may seem obvious but the fast-paced nature of large-scale, labor-intensive environments is not conducive to investing time and resources into managerial training, especially in non-technical capacities. And yet, proficiency in soft skills is crucial for a safer and healthier workplace, and a more productive workforce.

Image credits: Nayantara Parikh